Stop installing xorg packages for Wayland profiles (#4348)

* Add WaylandProfile to avoid installing xorg packages for Wayland compositors

* Refactor: use composition (is_wayland) instead of WaylandProfile inheritance

* Fix X11 profiles to inherit xorg packages from XorgProfile

* Style: use consistent multi-line super().__init__ for Wayland profiles

* Refactor: replace is_wayland with DisplayServerType enum

Add DisplayServerType enum (Xorg/Wayland) to Profile. All profiles
now inherit Profile directly with an explicit display_server param.
desktop.py installs xorg-server and xorg-xinit for Xorg profiles.
XorgProfile remains for standalone Xorg selection.

* Remove unnecessary super().packages from desktop profiles

archinstall/default_profiles/desktop.py

@@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ from __future__ import annotations
 
 from typing import TYPE_CHECKING, Self, override
 
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType, SelectResult
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType, SelectResult
 from archinstall.lib.menu.helpers import Selection
 from archinstall.lib.output import info
 from archinstall.lib.profile.profiles_handler import profile_handler
@@ -95,10 +95,16 @@ class DesktopProfile(Profile):
 		# Install common packages for all desktop environments
 		install_session.add_additional_packages(self.packages)
 
+		xorg_installed = False
+
 		for profile in self.current_selection:
 			info(f'Installing profile {profile.name}...')
 
 			install_session.add_additional_packages(profile.packages)
 			install_session.enable_service(profile.services)
 
+			if not xorg_installed and profile.display_server == DisplayServerType.Xorg:
+				install_session.add_additional_packages(['xorg-server', 'xorg-xinit'])
+				xorg_installed = True
+
 			profile.install(install_session)

archinstall/default_profiles/desktops/awesome.py

@@ -2,24 +2,27 @@ from __future__ import annotations
 
 from typing import TYPE_CHECKING, override
 
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import ProfileType
-from archinstall.default_profiles.xorg import XorgProfile
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, Profile, ProfileType
 
 if TYPE_CHECKING:
 	from archinstall.lib.installer import Installer
 
 
-class AwesomeProfile(XorgProfile):
+class AwesomeProfile(Profile):
 	def __init__(self) -> None:
-		super().__init__('Awesome', ProfileType.WindowMgr)
+		super().__init__(
+			'Awesome',
+			ProfileType.WindowMgr,
+			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Xorg,
+		)
 
 	@property
 	@override
 	def packages(self) -> list[str]:
-		return super().packages + [
+		return [
 			'awesome',
 			'alacritty',
-			'xorg-xinit',
 			'xorg-xrandr',
 			'xterm',
 			'feh',

archinstall/default_profiles/desktops/bspwm.py

@@ -1,17 +1,20 @@
 from typing import override
 
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import GreeterType, ProfileType
-from archinstall.default_profiles.xorg import XorgProfile
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType
 
 
-class BspwmProfile(XorgProfile):
+class BspwmProfile(Profile):
 	def __init__(self) -> None:
-		super().__init__('Bspwm', ProfileType.WindowMgr)
+		super().__init__(
+			'Bspwm',
+			ProfileType.WindowMgr,
+			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Xorg,
+		)
 
 	@property
 	@override
 	def packages(self) -> list[str]:
-		# return super().packages + [
 		return [
 			'bspwm',
 			'sxhkd',

archinstall/default_profiles/desktops/budgie.py

@@ -1,12 +1,16 @@
 from typing import override
 
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import GreeterType, ProfileType
-from archinstall.default_profiles.xorg import XorgProfile
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType
 
 
-class BudgieProfile(XorgProfile):
+class BudgieProfile(Profile):
 	def __init__(self) -> None:
-		super().__init__('Budgie', ProfileType.DesktopEnv)
+		super().__init__(
+			'Budgie',
+			ProfileType.DesktopEnv,
+			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Xorg,
+		)
 
 	@property
 	@override

archinstall/default_profiles/desktops/cinnamon.py

@@ -1,12 +1,16 @@
 from typing import override
 
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import GreeterType, ProfileType
-from archinstall.default_profiles.xorg import XorgProfile
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType
 
 
-class CinnamonProfile(XorgProfile):
+class CinnamonProfile(Profile):
 	def __init__(self) -> None:
-		super().__init__('Cinnamon', ProfileType.DesktopEnv)
+		super().__init__(
+			'Cinnamon',
+			ProfileType.DesktopEnv,
+			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Xorg,
+		)
 
 	@property
 	@override

archinstall/default_profiles/desktops/cosmic.py

@@ -1,12 +1,16 @@
 from typing import override
 
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import GreeterType, ProfileType
-from archinstall.default_profiles.xorg import XorgProfile
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType
 
 
-class CosmicProfile(XorgProfile):
+class CosmicProfile(Profile):
 	def __init__(self) -> None:
-		super().__init__('Cosmic', ProfileType.DesktopEnv)
+		super().__init__(
+			'Cosmic',
+			ProfileType.DesktopEnv,
+			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Wayland,
+		)
 
 	@property
 	@override

archinstall/default_profiles/desktops/cutefish.py

@@ -1,12 +1,16 @@
 from typing import override
 
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import GreeterType, ProfileType
-from archinstall.default_profiles.xorg import XorgProfile
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType
 
 
-class CutefishProfile(XorgProfile):
+class CutefishProfile(Profile):
 	def __init__(self) -> None:
-		super().__init__('Cutefish', ProfileType.DesktopEnv)
+		super().__init__(
+			'Cutefish',
+			ProfileType.DesktopEnv,
+			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Xorg,
+		)
 
 	@property
 	@override

archinstall/default_profiles/desktops/deepin.py

@@ -1,12 +1,16 @@
 from typing import override
 
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import GreeterType, ProfileType
-from archinstall.default_profiles.xorg import XorgProfile
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType
 
 
-class DeepinProfile(XorgProfile):
+class DeepinProfile(Profile):
 	def __init__(self) -> None:
-		super().__init__('Deepin', ProfileType.DesktopEnv)
+		super().__init__(
+			'Deepin',
+			ProfileType.DesktopEnv,
+			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Xorg,
+		)
 
 	@property
 	@override

archinstall/default_profiles/desktops/enlightenment.py

@@ -1,12 +1,16 @@
 from typing import override
 
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import GreeterType, ProfileType
-from archinstall.default_profiles.xorg import XorgProfile
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType
 
 
-class EnlightenmentProfile(XorgProfile):
+class EnlightenmentProfile(Profile):
 	def __init__(self) -> None:
-		super().__init__('Enlightenment', ProfileType.WindowMgr)
+		super().__init__(
+			'Enlightenment',
+			ProfileType.WindowMgr,
+			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Xorg,
+		)
 
 	@property
 	@override

archinstall/default_profiles/desktops/gnome.py

@@ -1,12 +1,16 @@
 from typing import override
 
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import GreeterType, ProfileType
-from archinstall.default_profiles.xorg import XorgProfile
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType
 
 
-class GnomeProfile(XorgProfile):
+class GnomeProfile(Profile):
 	def __init__(self) -> None:
-		super().__init__('GNOME', ProfileType.DesktopEnv)
+		super().__init__(
+			'GNOME',
+			ProfileType.DesktopEnv,
+			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Wayland,
+		)
 
 	@property
 	@override

archinstall/default_profiles/desktops/hyprland.py

@@ -1,17 +1,21 @@
 from typing import override
 
 from archinstall.default_profiles.desktops import SeatAccess
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import GreeterType, ProfileType
-from archinstall.default_profiles.xorg import XorgProfile
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType
 from archinstall.lib.menu.helpers import Selection
 from archinstall.lib.translationhandler import tr
 from archinstall.tui.ui.menu_item import MenuItem, MenuItemGroup
 from archinstall.tui.ui.result import ResultType
 
 
-class HyprlandProfile(XorgProfile):
+class HyprlandProfile(Profile):
 	def __init__(self) -> None:
-		super().__init__('Hyprland', ProfileType.DesktopEnv)
+		super().__init__(
+			'Hyprland',
+			ProfileType.DesktopEnv,
+			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Wayland,
+		)
 
 		self.custom_settings = {'seat_access': None}
 

archinstall/default_profiles/desktops/i3.py

@@ -1,12 +1,16 @@
 from typing import override
 
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import GreeterType, ProfileType
-from archinstall.default_profiles.xorg import XorgProfile
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType
 
 
-class I3wmProfile(XorgProfile):
+class I3wmProfile(Profile):
 	def __init__(self) -> None:
-		super().__init__('i3-wm', ProfileType.WindowMgr)
+		super().__init__(
+			'i3-wm',
+			ProfileType.WindowMgr,
+			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Xorg,
+		)
 
 	@property
 	@override

archinstall/default_profiles/desktops/labwc.py

@@ -1,19 +1,20 @@
 from typing import override
 
 from archinstall.default_profiles.desktops import SeatAccess
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import GreeterType, ProfileType
-from archinstall.default_profiles.xorg import XorgProfile
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType
 from archinstall.lib.menu.helpers import Selection
 from archinstall.lib.translationhandler import tr
 from archinstall.tui.ui.menu_item import MenuItem, MenuItemGroup
 from archinstall.tui.ui.result import ResultType
 
 
-class LabwcProfile(XorgProfile):
+class LabwcProfile(Profile):
 	def __init__(self) -> None:
 		super().__init__(
 			'Labwc',
 			ProfileType.WindowMgr,
+			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Wayland,
 		)
 
 		self.custom_settings = {'seat_access': None}

archinstall/default_profiles/desktops/lxqt.py

@@ -1,12 +1,16 @@
 from typing import override
 
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import GreeterType, ProfileType
-from archinstall.default_profiles.xorg import XorgProfile
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType
 
 
-class LxqtProfile(XorgProfile):
+class LxqtProfile(Profile):
 	def __init__(self) -> None:
-		super().__init__('Lxqt', ProfileType.DesktopEnv)
+		super().__init__(
+			'Lxqt',
+			ProfileType.DesktopEnv,
+			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Xorg,
+		)
 
 	# NOTE: SDDM is the only officially supported greeter for LXQt, so unlike other DEs, lightdm is not used here.
 	# LXQt works with lightdm, but since this is not supported, we will not default to this.

archinstall/default_profiles/desktops/mate.py

@@ -1,12 +1,16 @@
 from typing import override
 
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import GreeterType, ProfileType
-from archinstall.default_profiles.xorg import XorgProfile
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType
 
 
-class MateProfile(XorgProfile):
+class MateProfile(Profile):
 	def __init__(self) -> None:
-		super().__init__('Mate', ProfileType.DesktopEnv)
+		super().__init__(
+			'Mate',
+			ProfileType.DesktopEnv,
+			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Xorg,
+		)
 
 	@property
 	@override

archinstall/default_profiles/desktops/niri.py

@@ -1,19 +1,20 @@
 from typing import override
 
 from archinstall.default_profiles.desktops import SeatAccess
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import GreeterType, ProfileType
-from archinstall.default_profiles.xorg import XorgProfile
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType
 from archinstall.lib.menu.helpers import Selection
 from archinstall.lib.translationhandler import tr
 from archinstall.tui.ui.menu_item import MenuItem, MenuItemGroup
 from archinstall.tui.ui.result import ResultType
 
 
-class NiriProfile(XorgProfile):
+class NiriProfile(Profile):
 	def __init__(self) -> None:
 		super().__init__(
 			'Niri',
 			ProfileType.WindowMgr,
+			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Wayland,
 		)
 
 		self.custom_settings = {'seat_access': None}

archinstall/default_profiles/desktops/plasma.py

@@ -1,12 +1,16 @@
 from typing import override
 
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import GreeterType, ProfileType
-from archinstall.default_profiles.xorg import XorgProfile
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType
 
 
-class PlasmaProfile(XorgProfile):
+class PlasmaProfile(Profile):
 	def __init__(self) -> None:
-		super().__init__('KDE Plasma', ProfileType.DesktopEnv)
+		super().__init__(
+			'KDE Plasma',
+			ProfileType.DesktopEnv,
+			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Wayland,
+		)
 
 	@property
 	@override

archinstall/default_profiles/desktops/qtile.py

@@ -1,12 +1,16 @@
 from typing import override
 
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import GreeterType, ProfileType
-from archinstall.default_profiles.xorg import XorgProfile
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType
 
 
-class QtileProfile(XorgProfile):
+class QtileProfile(Profile):
 	def __init__(self) -> None:
-		super().__init__('Qtile', ProfileType.WindowMgr)
+		super().__init__(
+			'Qtile',
+			ProfileType.WindowMgr,
+			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Xorg,
+		)
 
 	@property
 	@override

archinstall/default_profiles/desktops/river.py

@@ -1,12 +1,16 @@
 from typing import override
 
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import GreeterType, ProfileType
-from archinstall.default_profiles.xorg import XorgProfile
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType
 
 
-class RiverProfile(XorgProfile):
+class RiverProfile(Profile):
 	def __init__(self) -> None:
-		super().__init__('River', ProfileType.WindowMgr)
+		super().__init__(
+			'River',
+			ProfileType.WindowMgr,
+			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Wayland,
+		)
 
 	@property
 	@override

archinstall/default_profiles/desktops/sway.py

@@ -1,19 +1,20 @@
 from typing import override
 
 from archinstall.default_profiles.desktops import SeatAccess
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import GreeterType, ProfileType
-from archinstall.default_profiles.xorg import XorgProfile
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType
 from archinstall.lib.menu.helpers import Selection
 from archinstall.lib.translationhandler import tr
 from archinstall.tui.ui.menu_item import MenuItem, MenuItemGroup
 from archinstall.tui.ui.result import ResultType
 
 
-class SwayProfile(XorgProfile):
+class SwayProfile(Profile):
 	def __init__(self) -> None:
 		super().__init__(
 			'Sway',
 			ProfileType.WindowMgr,
+			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Wayland,
 		)
 
 		self.custom_settings = {'seat_access': None}

archinstall/default_profiles/desktops/xfce4.py

@@ -1,12 +1,16 @@
 from typing import override
 
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import GreeterType, ProfileType
-from archinstall.default_profiles.xorg import XorgProfile
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType
 
 
-class Xfce4Profile(XorgProfile):
+class Xfce4Profile(Profile):
 	def __init__(self) -> None:
-		super().__init__('Xfce4', ProfileType.DesktopEnv)
+		super().__init__(
+			'Xfce4',
+			ProfileType.DesktopEnv,
+			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Xorg,
+		)
 
 	@property
 	@override

archinstall/default_profiles/desktops/xmonad.py

@@ -1,12 +1,16 @@
 from typing import override
 
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import GreeterType, ProfileType
-from archinstall.default_profiles.xorg import XorgProfile
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, GreeterType, Profile, ProfileType
 
 
-class XmonadProfile(XorgProfile):
+class XmonadProfile(Profile):
 	def __init__(self) -> None:
-		super().__init__('Xmonad', ProfileType.WindowMgr)
+		super().__init__(
+			'Xmonad',
+			ProfileType.WindowMgr,
+			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Xorg,
+		)
 
 	@property
 	@override

archinstall/default_profiles/profile.py

@@ -10,6 +10,11 @@ if TYPE_CHECKING:
 	from archinstall.lib.models.users import User
 
 
+class DisplayServerType(Enum):
+	Xorg = 'Xorg'
+	Wayland = 'Wayland'
+
+
 class ProfileType(Enum):
 	# top level default_profiles
 	Server = 'Server'
@@ -52,6 +57,7 @@ class Profile:
 		services: list[str] = [],
 		support_gfx_driver: bool = False,
 		support_greeter: bool = False,
+		display_server: DisplayServerType | None = None,
 	) -> None:
 		self.name = name
 		self.profile_type = profile_type
@@ -59,6 +65,7 @@ class Profile:
 
 		self._support_gfx_driver = support_gfx_driver
 		self._support_greeter = support_greeter
+		self._display_server = display_server
 
 		# self.gfx_driver: str | None = None
 
@@ -169,10 +176,23 @@ class Profile:
 	def is_greeter_supported(self) -> bool:
 		return self._support_greeter
 
+	@property
+	def display_server(self) -> DisplayServerType | None:
+		return self._display_server
+
 	def preview_text(self) -> str:
 		"""
 		Override this method to provide a preview text for the profile
 		"""
+		if self.is_desktop_type_profile():
+			if self._display_server:
+				text = tr('Environment type: {} {}').format(self._display_server.value, self.profile_type.value)
+			else:
+				text = tr('Environment type: {}').format(self.profile_type.value)
+			if packages := self.packages_text():
+				text += f'\n{packages}'
+			return text
+
 		return self.packages_text()
 
 	def packages_text(self, include_sub_packages: bool = False) -> str:

archinstall/default_profiles/xorg.py

@@ -1,7 +1,9 @@
-from typing import override
+from typing import TYPE_CHECKING, override
 
-from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import Profile, ProfileType
-from archinstall.lib.translationhandler import tr
+from archinstall.default_profiles.profile import DisplayServerType, Profile, ProfileType
+
+if TYPE_CHECKING:
+	from archinstall.lib.installer import Installer
 
 
 class XorgProfile(Profile):
@@ -14,19 +16,17 @@ class XorgProfile(Profile):
 			name,
 			profile_type,
 			support_gfx_driver=True,
+			display_server=DisplayServerType.Xorg,
 		)
 
-	@override
-	def preview_text(self) -> str:
-		text = tr('Environment type: {}').format(self.profile_type.value)
-		if packages := self.packages_text():
-			text += f'\n{packages}'
-
-		return text
-
 	@property
 	@override
 	def packages(self) -> list[str]:
 		return [
 			'xorg-server',
+			'xorg-xinit',
 		]
+
+	@override
+	def install(self, install_session: Installer) -> None:
+		install_session.add_additional_packages(self.packages)

archinstall/lib/hardware.py

@@ -51,8 +51,6 @@ class GfxPackage(Enum):
 	Xf86VideoAmdgpu = 'xf86-video-amdgpu'
 	Xf86VideoAti = 'xf86-video-ati'
 	Xf86VideoNouveau = 'xf86-video-nouveau'
-	XorgServer = 'xorg-server'
-	XorgXinit = 'xorg-xinit'
 
 
 class GfxDriver(Enum):
@@ -80,7 +78,7 @@ class GfxDriver(Enum):
 		return text
 
 	def gfx_packages(self) -> list[GfxPackage]:
-		packages = [GfxPackage.XorgServer, GfxPackage.XorgXinit]
+		packages: list[GfxPackage] = []
 
 		match self:
 			case GfxDriver.AllOpenSource:

archinstall/lib/profile/profiles_handler.py

@@ -349,8 +349,8 @@ class ProfileHandler:
 		profiles_path = Path(__file__).parents[2] / 'default_profiles'
 		profiles = []
 		for file in profiles_path.glob('**/*.py'):
-			# ignore the abstract default_profiles class
-			if 'profile.py' in file.name:
+			# ignore the abstract base classes
+			if file.name == 'profile.py':
 				continue
 			profiles += self._process_profile_file(file)