mirror of https://github.com/garrytan/gstack.git
3e7251a2e6
Closes #2496, #2524, #2477 — three defects in the class "a guard that reports success while doing nothing", all in codex/SKILL.md.tmpl: (a) Review sandbox. The default `codex review` path was the only codex call with no sandbox override, inheriting ~/.codex/config.toml's default — write access on a trusted project — while Important Rules claimed read-only. Top-level `codex review` has no -s/--sandbox flag (verified on 0.147.0), so the invocation now pins `-c 'sandbox_mode="read-only"'`, the same form the consult-resume path already uses. (b) Fail-closed verdict gate. The old rule ("no [P1] found → PASS") could not fail on the default path: native `codex review` output carries no bracketed tags, and a non-zero exit, expired auth, timeout, or empty result also contains no [P1] — all read as PASS. The gate is now an ordered, fail-closed check: non-zero exit → FAIL; empty output → FAIL; [P0]/[P1] (bracketed or codex's native labels) → FAIL with count; NO severity tags at all → FAIL requiring a human read; PASS is only reachable through the explicit tagged-advisory-only branch. [P0] is recognized as blocking, and the review-log findings count includes it. (c) Bash gate above the wrapper. Step 2A instructed `timeout: 300000` under a 330s wrapper, and Challenge's 300s gate sat under a 600s wrapper — the harness killed the call before the wrapper could emit its diagnosable exit-124 message. Every Bash gate now sits strictly ABOVE its wrapper: 360000 over the 330s review wrapper, 660000 over the 600s challenge/consult wrappers, with the ordering rationale stated at each site. Also from #2477/#2524: a new Error Handling entry for the model-entitlement 400 ("The '<model>' model is not supported...") pointing at the `model =` pin and `[notice.model_migrations]` in ~/.codex/config.toml and saying exactly which override to retry with (-m for exec-based modes, `-c model="..."` for review mode, which rejects -m); the Model & Reasoning section no longer documents `-m` for `/codex review`. Static assertions in test/codex-hardening.test.ts pin (a)-(c) across both the .tmpl and the generated SKILL.md: every scoped review invocation carries sandbox_mode="read-only" and never -s; the default-PASS sentence is banned and the fail-closed branches are present; and per-section, every Bash `timeout: N` is strictly greater than every wrapper budget, with 2A/2B/2C all required to be inspected. Generated SKILL.md regenerated via gen:skill-docs in this commit. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> |
||
|---|---|---|
| .. | ||
| SKILL.md | ||
| SKILL.md.tmpl | ||