mirror of https://github.com/garrytan/gstack.git
aa49339b27
Ship-workflow review re-dispatched the testing specialist against the full
updated diff (including the new minimal-change eval) and found 3 more real
bugs in the same family as the earlier fix pass:
- matchesUnnegated's fixed 20-char negation lookback was too narrow: the
patterns it guards have their own internal gaps up to 80 chars, so "I do
not think it's worth extracting the payload into columns" (negation >20
chars before the match) would be misread as an unnegated recommendation.
Now scans back to the start of the current sentence (last ./!/? before the
match) instead of a fixed count — matches the same period-bounded
assumption the calling patterns already make.
- Verified during the fix: neither "not"/"never"/etc. nor the wider window
catches contrastive phrasing ("add this field to the model RATHER THAN
create a separate table") — the rejected alternative matches the pattern
just as strongly as a genuine recommendation, with no negation word
anywhere nearby. Added "rather than"/"instead of" to the shared negation
list, benefiting all four callers, not just the new eval.
- The new minimal-change eval's acceptsInlineAddition check was missing the
matchesUnnegated guard entirely on its first alternative (unlike its
sibling recommendsSeparateModel a few lines above), and
recommendsSeparateModel's verb list missed common recommendation phrasings
(introduce, build, spin out, break out) — deliberately did NOT add "add",
since "add this new field to the existing model" is exactly how the
CORRECT answer gets phrased.
Added 3 unit tests reproducing the sentence-boundary and contrastive-phrasing
fixes directly (not just via the paid E2E path).
bun test test/helpers/e2e-helpers.test.ts test/skill-e2e-plan.test.ts
test/skill-validation.test.ts test/parity-suite.test.ts test/touchfiles.test.ts
test/gen-skill-docs.test.ts — 781 pass, 42 skip (paid E2E), 0 fail.
|
||
|---|---|---|
| .. | ||
| providers | ||
| agent-sdk-runner.ts | ||
| auq-sdk-capture.ts | ||
| benchmark-judge.ts | ||
| benchmark-runner.ts | ||
| budget-override.test.ts | ||
| budget-override.ts | ||
| capture-parity-baseline.test.ts | ||
| capture-parity-baseline.ts | ||
| carve-guard-checks.ts | ||
| carve-guards.ts | ||
| claude-pty-runner.ts | ||
| claude-pty-runner.unit.test.ts | ||
| codex-session-runner.ts | ||
| e2e-helpers.test.ts | ||
| e2e-helpers.ts | ||
| eval-store.test.ts | ||
| eval-store.ts | ||
| gemini-session-runner.test.ts | ||
| gemini-session-runner.ts | ||
| hermetic-env.test.ts | ||
| hermetic-env.ts | ||
| llm-judge.ts | ||
| observability.test.ts | ||
| parity-harness.ts | ||
| pricing.ts | ||
| required-reads.ts | ||
| secret-sink-harness.ts | ||
| session-runner.test.ts | ||
| session-runner.ts | ||
| skill-parser.ts | ||
| tool-map.ts | ||
| touchfiles.ts | ||
| transcript-section-logger.ts | ||