Commit Graph

5 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Ben Kamholtz 5a8102d71c fix(a2a): JSON-RPC conformance for a2a-sdk 1.1.0 compatibility
Two bugs reported by gfdsa (PR #41711 comment, Jul 12) that break the
official a2a-sdk 1.1.0 Python client:

1. Task objects serialized non-spec createdAt/lastModified fields.
   The A2A v1.0 Task proto (lf.a2a.v1.Task) only has id, contextId,
   status, artifacts, history, metadata. Strict ProtoJSON parsers
   reject unknown fields with ParseError. Removed both fields from
   build_task(); created_at param kept for call-site compatibility.

2. SSE streaming frames were not JSON-RPC wrapped. A2A v1.0 §9.4
   requires data: {"jsonrpc":"2.0","id":...,"result":{StreamResponse}}.
   sse_data() now accepts req_id and wraps in JSON-RPC envelope.
   sse_done() changed from 'data: {}' to SSE comment ': done' so
   SDK doesn't try to parse an empty JSON-RPC response.

All call sites in adapter.py (_emit_terminal, _rpc_message_stream,
_rpc_tasks_subscribe) updated to thread req_id through.

Tests updated: 153 pass (151 unit + 17 integration, including 2 new
tests for JSON-RPC envelope wrapping and fallback behavior).

Refs: gfdsa/a2a-hermes reproduction repo
2026-08-02 15:10:15 -07:00
Kevin (OpenClaw Bot) b1819ceb7d fix(a2a): align multiplexer with v1 protocol and tenant isolation 2026-08-02 15:10:15 -07:00
Kevin (OpenClaw Bot) 41c406e1ab feat(a2a): v1.0 upgrade + full code review fixes
Fable 5 pass: 40 turns, $13.56, 109k output tokens.

## A2A v1.0 upgrade
- SCREAMING_SNAKE task states (TASK_STATE_COMPLETED etc)
- ROLE_USER/ROLE_AGENT message roles
- Unified Parts (no kind field, member-presence discrimination)
- Agent Card: supportedInterfaces[], provider, capabilities.extendedAgentCard
- SSE: member-discriminated statusUpdate/artifactUpdate, closure=terminal
- contextId inside Message (not top-level params)
- ISO 8601 millisecond timestamps, createdAt/lastModified on Task
- New operations: tasks/list, tasks/subscribe
- input-required state reachable via [INPUT_REQUIRED] hint

## Security & correctness (all must-fix from review)
- Slash-command bypass removed — remote peers can't invoke operator commands
- Per-peer token auth (A2A_PEER_TOKENS) replaces self-asserted params.peer
- _pending_replies keyed by task_id with per-context FIFO (no cross-talk)
- Timeout returns TASK_STATE_FAILED, not completed
- reset_turns uses task's context from store (was silent no-op)
- Error codes: spec codes only for spec semantics, custom -32050..-32052
- Real latency metric (was fake 0.0)

## Dead features wired
- Push notifications: inline configuration.taskPushNotificationConfig in
  message/send + tasks/pushNotificationConfig/create. HMAC-signed e2e.
- Dynamic Agent Cards: skills from live tools.registry, A2A_ADVERTISED_TOOLSETS
- Persistence: new a2a_history(context_id) tool recalls conversations
- Dead helpers cut: rate_limit_status, is_open_mode, verify_push_signature,
  turn_count, check_bearer

## Architecture
- TurnTracker/RateLimiter/TaskStore on adapter instance (was module-global)
- Handler class at module level (was untestable closure)
- on_processing_complete for failure/cancel paths
- SSE hang fix: keepalive header no longer prevents socket closure

## a2a_orchestrate kept per user instruction
- best mode: only successful replies considered (long error can't win)
- all-error case: explicit 'All peers failed' listing
- Client paths deduped into _send_task helper

## Tests
- inspect.getsource() tests replaced with behavioral coverage
- 133 total: 118 unit + 15 integration
- v1.0 spec compliance, peer-token auth, FIFO replies, timeout→FAILED,
  tasks/get-after-complete, streaming SSE parse, subscribe replay,
  anti-loop rejection, 429s, push e2e, input-required e2e, orchestrate

## Docs
- DESIGN.md out-of-scope synced with reality
- README and plugin.yaml updated

Still TODO (in DESIGN.md): file/data Parts, push-config get/list/delete,
tenant, gRPC/HTTP+JSON bindings, true mid-turn task abort.
2026-08-02 15:10:15 -07:00
Kevin (OpenClaw Bot) 37481dccf4 fix(a2a): security hardening from code review
Critical fixes:
- SSRF protection: validate push notification callback URLs (block
  internal/private/loopback/metadata, enforce http/https only)
- Request body size limit: 1MB max (prevents memory exhaustion DoS)
- Thread safety: module-level locks for turn tracking, rate limiting,
  and pending task registry (was lazily initialized, racy)
- Peer identity: fall back to client IP when 'peer' field absent
  (prevents rate limiting collapse to single 'unknown' bucket)

Minor fixes:
- Watchdog survives reconnect: clear _watchdog_stop in connect()
- Redact error messages before sending to peers
- Remove dead _streaming_queues state
- Fix duplicate tags key in Agent Card skills
- Always send contextId in a2a_call (fixes client/server mismatch)
- Clear push_callbacks on disconnect
- SSE streaming cleanup via try/finally

16 new tests covering SSRF, body size, thread safety, watchdog
reconnect, error redaction, contextId consistency.
Tests: 97 passed, 3 deselected, 0 failed.
2026-08-02 15:10:15 -07:00
Kevin (OpenClaw Bot) c6b0e3a80e feat(a2a): Phase 2+3 — SSE streaming, push notifications, anti-loop, orchestrate
Phase 2 (production features):
- SSE streaming: message/stream endpoint with proper event formatting
  (submitted → working → completed → done), keepalive pings
- Push notifications: HMAC-SHA256 signed webhooks via
  tasks/pushNotification/set, auto-fired on task completion
- Rate limiting: token-bucket per peer (A2A_RATE_LIMIT, default 60/min)
- Metrics: /metrics endpoint with counters, latency tracking, uptime
- Orphaned task watchdog: background thread cleans stale tasks (>300s)

Phase 3 (OpenClaw patterns):
- Anti-loop ping-pong: per-context turn counter with configurable
  max (A2A_MAX_PINGPONG_TURNS, default 5, max 20)
- Async durable messaging: pending task registry with register/
  complete/orphaned/clear lifecycle
- Capability-based routing: a2a_orchestrate tool with fan-out modes
  (all/first/best), matches peers by capabilities in config
- Dynamic Agent Cards: skills_from_real_toolsets() builds skill cards
  from actual toolset registry, not just names
- Trusted-peer approval (#56434): A2A_TRUSTED_PEERS env/config,
  is_trusted_peer() gate in inbound handler
- Task completion notifications (#56435): build_task includes
  status.message + artifacts for completed/failed states

Agent Card version bumped to 0.2.0, capabilities now advertise
streaming=True and pushNotifications=True.

Tests: 81 passed (45 existing + 36 new), 0 failed.
2026-08-02 15:10:15 -07:00