* fix(model-picker): serve cached custom-provider catalog on no-probe opens
#58183 stopped GUI picker opens from live-probing saved custom
OpenAI-compatible endpoints so a stopped local server could not stall the
picker. It gated the whole discovery block, not just the network call, so
`cached_fetch_api_models()` was skipped too — and with it the catalog an
earlier probe had already written to `provider_models_cache.json`.
A custom endpoint that is not the current provider therefore renders only
the models named in its config entry. A local server with 8 models loaded
shows the 1 model that was saved when the provider was first added, on
every picker open, while an explicit Refresh shows all 8.
Add `cache_only` to `cached_fetch_api_models()`: answer from disk within
the existing stale-serve window, never fetch, never revalidate off-thread,
return None on a miss. Split the three call sites in
`list_authenticated_providers()` into what the user's config permits
(`discover_models`, an explicit `models:` allowlist) and how we may obtain
it, so suppressing the probe now downgrades to a cached read instead of
skipping discovery outright. `discover_models: false` still pins, and a
cache hit no longer writes back to config since the probe that populated
it already did.
The latency win stands: a cold cache is a miss, so picker opens against
offline endpoints still make zero network calls.
* test(model-picker): pin the cached-catalog contract for no-probe opens
Cover both halves of the invariant, since fixing either one alone
reintroduces a bug the other guards against.
`cache_only` on `cached_fetch_api_models()`: a fresh entry and an entry
past its TTL but inside the stale-serve window both serve; an entry beyond
that window, an empty cache, rotated credentials, `force_refresh`, and a
missing base_url are all misses — and none of them fetch or spawn a
background revalidation.
`list_authenticated_providers()` on the GUI path: a non-current endpoint
with a warm cache reports its full catalog across all three provider
shapes (`custom_providers`, `providers:`, bare `provider: custom`) with no
live fetch attempted. A cold cache keeps the configured list and still
makes no network call, which is the #58183 guarantee. `discover_models:
false` keeps pinning, and a cache hit does not write back to config.
* fix: persist discovered custom-provider models in the hermes model flow
The `hermes model` named-custom-provider flow (_model_flow_named_custom)
probes the endpoint and shows the full catalog, but never persists it to the
entry's `models:` list. No-probe surfaces (dashboard, desktop, ACP) call
build_models_payload(..., probe_custom_providers=False) and only render the
configured `models:` list, so a provider added via `hermes model` collapses
to the single `model:` default everywhere except the CLI. OpenAI-compatible
providers added via a probing picker already benefit from
_save_discovered_models_to_config; the CLI flow did not.
Persist the live catalog after a successful probe, mirroring the picker path
in model_switch.py. A failed save is non-fatal.
* fix(model-picker): stop an auto-saved catalog pinning a keyless endpoint
The cached-catalog read added for no-probe picker opens still sat behind
the no-key discovery gate, so it never reached the shape that motivated
it: a keyless local model server.
`bool(api_key) or not has_explicit_models` is a network-cost gate. It
exists so Hermes does not probe an endpoint it cannot authenticate to
when that endpoint already declares its catalog (5f00f36ba, 1039e90b5).
Reading a catalog an earlier probe already paid for costs nothing, so
the gate belongs on the probe, not on discovery as a whole.
Left on the discovery side it re-pins the endpoint it was meant to
spare. A successful probe calls `_save_discovered_models_to_config()`,
which writes a plain list into `models:` — exactly the shape
`_models_config_is_allowlist()` reads back as an explicit user
allowlist. A keyless server therefore froze on the catalog of its first
probe and could never widen again, which is the "lineup changes after
config was written" case. f66319097 already carved the dict shape out of
this trap for the same reason; the list shape is the other door into it.
Move the clause to `_probe_live` at both custom-endpoint sites. Probe
suppression is unchanged — verified byte-identical to main across the
keyed/keyless x declared/undeclared matrix — and `discover_models: false`
remains the documented way to pin a catalog.
* test(model-picker): cover the keyless auto-save pinning trap
Three tests around the gate move, each failing on the code before it:
- a keyless endpoint carrying an auto-saved `models:` list still reads
its full cached catalog
- the same row, cold cache and probing enabled, still makes zero live
fetches — the network-cost gate the clause exists for
- an end-to-end round trip: persist a probe result via
`_save_discovered_models_to_config()`, reload it, and assert the shape
we wrote does not read back as a user pin
The round-trip test guards the whole chain rather than one branch, so a
future change that makes the saved shape look like an intentional
allowlist fails here even if the gate logic is refactored.
* fix(model-picker): key the custom-endpoint model cache by api_mode
`cached_fetch_api_models()` fingerprints entries with `api_mode`, but no
call site in `list_authenticated_providers()` passed it, so every custom
row resolved to the `api_mode=None` fingerprint. Two rows sharing a
base_url and credential but differing by `api_mode` are deliberately
distinct picker rows — it is part of `group_key` at both sites — yet they
collapsed onto one cache entry.
That was latent while probing was the only way to fill a row: a mismatched
entry was overwritten by the row's own live fetch. Serving that entry
without a probe makes it visible, so an `anthropic_messages` row could
render the catalog an OpenAI-mode row cached against the same URL. The
wire protocols differ (`x-api-key` + `anthropic-version` vs
`Authorization: Bearer`), so those catalogs are not interchangeable.
Persist `api_mode` on the group at both grouping sites — it is already
part of `group_key`, so it is constant across the group — and pass it
into the cache read. Section 3b (bare `provider: custom`) has no
`api_mode` in scope and already reads with the empty-credential
fingerprint, so it is unchanged.
Reported by Copilot review on #81973.
---------
Co-authored-by: xxxigm <tuancanhnguyen706@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Navlem <114683850+Navlem@users.noreply.github.com>
- Give cached_fetch_api_models the same stale-while-revalidate tier as
cached_provider_model_ids: TTL-expired entries within the 7d window are
served instantly while a background refresh rewrites the cache —
without this, every /model open an hour into the session re-blocked on
the live probe (#72762's stall class, deferred).
- Generalize _spawn_swr_refresh(cache_key, refresh_fn) so non-slug
custom:<base_url> keys reuse the same inflight-dedupe scaffolding;
slug behavior unchanged (default refresh_fn preserved).
- Convert the missed sibling site: acp_adapter/server.py
_named_custom_provider_catalogs() live-probed every custom_providers
row's /v1/models per ACP catalog build.
- Extract _cache_entry_valid() (the fp/models predicate existed 4x) and
validate 'at' is numeric so hand-edited/corrupt cache JSON degrades to
a live fetch instead of raising through the picker's blanket except.
- Flatten the dead api_mode conditional (fetch_api_models declares
api_mode=None; branch was behaviorally inert).
- Tests: 4 new guards (stale-serve, stale-window cutoff, generalized SWR
write-through, corrupt-at degradation) — stale-serve and corrupt-at
mutation-checked; 2 existing tests updated for the new behavior.
Three tests pin the exact kwargs of the picker probe call
(test_model_switch_custom_providers + two in
test_user_providers_model_switch, the latter caught by CI slice 2);
the picker-timeout change now always passes timeout explicitly (5.0 on
the non-picker path), so the pinned shapes gain the key.
Use providers keys as the canonical custom-provider identity while accepting legacy bare keys, display-name slugs, bare custom fallback, and doubled custom prefixes across resolution, pickers, doctor, and runtime reverse lookup.
Co-authored-by: Bakhtier Sizhaev <bakhtiersizhaev@users.noreply.github.com>
Second, deeper pass over tools/gateway/hermes_cli plus first pass over
the trees wave 1 missed (acp, acp_adapter, skills, computer_use, docker,
dashboard, conformance, monitoring, secret_sources, hermes_state,
providers). Same rubric as wave 1 (AGENTS.md test policy); security,
alternation/caching invariants, issue-number regressions, and E2E kept.
Real test-quality fixes found and rooted out along the way:
- tests/tools/test_command_guards.py made real auxiliary-LLM HTTPS calls
(DEFAULT_CONFIG smart-approval leaked in) — pinned approval
mode=manual via autouse fixture: 17.4s → 0.4s.
- test_model_switch_custom_providers.py / test_user_providers_model_switch.py
silently probed live provider catalogs (~2s/test) — stubbed
cached_provider_model_ids/provider_model_ids/fetch_api_models.
- test_telegram_noise_filter.py: 15-platform copy-paste matrix over
shared gateway.run logic → 3 representative platforms (55s → 3.9s).
- test_gateway_shutdown.py: stop()'s 5s interrupt-deadline loop spun on
MagicMock agents — interrupt.side_effect now clears _running_agents
(22s → 1.0s).
- test_gateway_inactivity_timeout.py poll-harness timings shrunk 3-5x
(24s → 1.1s); test_mcp_stability.py backoff/SIGTERM-grace sleeps
patched (15.4s → 2.5s); test_async_delegation.py negative-drain wait
5s → 0.5s.
- test_telegram_init_deadline.py: loop-block margin restored to 1.0s
with rationale comment — the watchdog-dump assertion needs the loop
blocked well past deadline+grace under parallel load (flaked once in
the 40-worker verification run at a 0.2s margin).
Verification: full hermetic suite via scripts/run_tests.sh —
2,438 files, 21,718 tests passed, 0 failed, 293.9s wall.
Suite totals vs original baseline: 46,820 → 19,757 test functions
(−57.8%), wall 583.5s → 293.9s (−50%), subprocess CPU 13,564s → 11,623s.
The dict-form guard from PR #67878 only covered the mapping shape
({model: {context_length: ...}}). The list-of-dicts shape
([{id: model, context_length: ...}]) is also a supported config form
(per _declared_model_ids) and was still being replaced with a flat
list of strings, destroying per-model metadata.
Sibling site for #67841.
When custom_providers[].models uses the mapping form to store
per-model metadata (e.g. context_length), _save_discovered_models_to_config
must not replace it with a flat list of strings. Add a guard that skips
entries whose models value is a dict, preserving the user's curated
metadata.
The regression was introduced by PR #65652, which added the auto-save
helper without considering the dict form.
* fix: speed up CLI /model picker by skipping non-current custom provider probing
The CLI /model picker calls build_models_payload() with default
probe_custom_providers=True, which live-fetches /v1/models from every
saved custom endpoint on every open. The GUI/desktop picker already
passes probe_custom_providers=False for snappiness.
Match the GUI behavior: skip probing non-current custom providers, but
still probe the current one so its model list stays accurate. Users can
force a full re-fetch with /model --refresh.
Fixes#65650
Related: #63583
* fix(cli): forward force_refresh to model picker probe flags
When /model --refresh is used, the CLI model picker must probe all
custom providers to refresh their model lists — not skip them.
Normal bare /model still skips non-current probes for speed.
Mirrors the existing desktop/TUI behavior. Add regression test for
both normal and refresh flag forwarding.
Fixes#65650
* fix: auto-save discovered models to config for discover-once caching
After a successful /v1/models probe, persist the discovered model list
back to config.yaml under the matching custom_providers entry. This
makes discover_models: false meaningful out of the box — users get a
populated cache after the first probe instead of a stale 1-model list.
- Add _save_discovered_models_to_config() helper
- Call after successful fetch_api_models in section 4 probe path
- Skip config write when model list hasn't changed
- Idempotent — no-op on empty api_url or model_ids
Tests: 4 new tests covering auto-save, empty-probe skip, unchanged
skip, and no-op-on-empty-args. All 4 pass.
Refs: #65652, #65650
---------
Co-authored-by: ajzrva-sys <302567740+ajzrva-sys@users.noreply.github.com>
Follow-up to @helix4u's #57336 salvage. Two review findings:
- W1: model-picker grouped custom-provider rows by
(api_url, credential, api_mode) but NOT extra_headers. Entries sharing a
URL+credential+api_mode yet declaring different headers (e.g. per-tenant
routing behind one proxy) collapsed into one row and probed /models with
whichever header set was seen first (order-dependent). Fold a canonical
header identity into group_key so distinct header-authed endpoints stay
separate; drops the now-dead first-non-empty merge branch.
- W2: the extra_headers stringify+None-filter comprehension existed in 5
copies (config.py x2, runtime_provider.py, model_switch.py, models.py).
Extract one shared hermes_cli.config.normalize_extra_headers primitive;
all sites now call it.
Tests: +normalize_extra_headers unit tests, +regression test proving two
same-endpoint entries with different headers stay distinct and each probes
with its own headers. 223 targeted tests pass; ruff clean.
resolve_custom_provider() previously returned api_key_env_vars=()
for every custom provider entry, silently dropping the configured
key_env field. This caused 401 errors for any custom provider that
required an API key via environment variable (e.g. Xiaomi MiMo Token
Plan, self-hosted OpenAI-compatible servers).
The key_env field is already documented in _VALID_CUSTOM_PROVIDER_FIELDS
and normalized by normalize_custom_provider_entry(), so this was just
an oversight in the ProviderDef construction.
Also adds a regression test that verifies key_env is properly
propagated into the resolved ProviderDef.
OpenCode Go (and OpenCode Zen) showed only a subset of the models they
serve in the desktop/CLI model picker — e.g. opencode-go rendered 13 of
19, silently dropping minimax-m3/m2.7/m2.5, glm-5/5.1, deepseek-v4-flash.
Root cause: the picker dedup in build_models_payload strips any model
from an aggregator row that overlaps a user-defined provider's catalog
(so a local proxy isn't shadowed by OpenRouter). It gated on
is_aggregator(), which is True for opencode-go/zen because their flat
/v1/models returns bare IDs the model-switch resolver searches. But
those are flat-namespace RESELLERS, not routing aggregators — every
model they list is first-party, so deduping them against a user proxy
that happens to serve a same-named model guts their own catalog.
Fix: add is_routing_aggregator() (True only for true routers like
OpenRouter and custom:* proxies; False for opencode-go/zen) and gate the
picker dedup on it. is_aggregator() is unchanged so model-switch flat
catalog resolution keeps working. Both desktop entry points
(model.options JSON-RPC and /api/model/options REST) and hermes model
share build_models_payload, so all surfaces get the full list.
Fixes#47077
Surface direct model.provider=custom endpoints in /model picker output and keep explicit bare custom switches on the current endpoint instead of requiring a named providers/custom_providers row.
Section 3 (user `providers:`) already honors `discover_models: false` to
skip live /models discovery and keep the explicit `models:` list. Section 4
(`custom_providers:` list) did not — `should_probe` ignored the field, so any
grouped custom provider with an api_key always had its configured subset
replaced by the full live /models catalog.
This adds the same `discover_models` support to section 4:
- Default True — no behaviour change for existing configs.
- `discover_models: false` keeps the explicit `models:` list even when an
api_key is present.
- String values ("false"/"no"/"0") are normalised to False, matching
section 3.
- If any entry in a grouped endpoint opts out, the whole group opts out.
Use case: endpoints that expose a full aggregator catalog via /models but
only serve a configured subset.
Salvaged from #29810 — rebased onto current main. The PR's other change
(`key_env` resolution in section 4) landed independently in commit aa283d1e4
(custom provider picker credential isolation), so only the discover_models
portion is carried here.
Co-authored-by: ohMyJason <42903577+ohMyJason@users.noreply.github.com>
custom_providers entries (section 4 of list_authenticated_providers) only
read the static models: dict from config.yaml, ignoring the live /v1/models
endpoint. This means gateways like Bifrost that expose hundreds of models
only show the handful explicitly listed in config.
Add live discovery via fetch_api_models() for custom_providers entries
that have api_key + base_url, matching the existing behavior for user
providers: entries (section 3). When the endpoint is reachable and
returns models, the live list replaces the static subset.
Fixes: /model picker showing only 9 models from a Bifrost gateway that
actually exposes 581.
/model kimi-k2.6 on opencode-zen (or glm-5.1 on opencode-go) returned OpenCode's
website 404 HTML page when the user's persisted model.default was a Claude or
MiniMax model. The switched-to chat_completions request hit
https://opencode.ai/zen (or /zen/go) with no /v1 suffix.
Root cause: resolve_runtime_provider() computed api_mode from
model_cfg.get('default') instead of the model being requested. With a Claude
default, it resolved api_mode=anthropic_messages, stripped /v1 from base_url
(required for the Anthropic SDK), then switch_model()'s opencode_model_api_mode
override flipped api_mode back to chat_completions without restoring /v1.
Fix: thread an optional target_model kwarg through resolve_runtime_provider
and _resolve_runtime_from_pool_entry. When the caller is performing an explicit
mid-session model switch (i.e. switch_model()), the target model drives both
api_mode selection and the conditional /v1 strip. Other callers (CLI init,
gateway init, cron, ACP, aux client, delegate, account_usage, tui_gateway) pass
nothing and preserve the existing config-default behavior.
Regression tests added in test_model_switch_opencode_anthropic.py use the REAL
resolver (not a mock) to guard the exact Quentin-repro scenario. Existing tests
that mocked resolve_runtime_provider with 'lambda requested:' had their mock
signatures widened to '**kwargs' to accept the new kwarg.
Multiple custom_providers entries sharing the same base_url + api_key
are now grouped into a single picker row. A local Ollama host with
per-model display names ("Ollama — GLM 5.1", "Ollama — Qwen3-coder",
"Ollama — Kimi K2", "Ollama — MiniMax M2.7") previously produced four
near-duplicate picker rows that differed only by suffix; now it appears
as one "Ollama" row with four models.
Key changes:
- Grouping key changed from slug-by-name to (base_url, api_key). Names
frequently differ per model while the endpoint stays the same.
- When the grouped endpoint matches current_base_url, the row's slug is
set to current_provider so picker-driven switches route through the
live credential pipeline (no re-resolution needed).
- Per-model suffix is stripped from the display name ("Ollama — X" →
"Ollama") via em-dash / " - " separators.
- Two groups with different api_keys at the same base_url (or otherwise
colliding on cleaned name) are disambiguated with a numeric suffix
(custom:openai, custom:openai-2) so both stay visible.
- current_base_url parameter plumbed through both gateway call sites.
Existing #8216, #11499, #13509 regressions covered (dict/list shapes
of models:, section-3/section-4 dedup, normalized list-format entries).
Salvaged from @davidvv's PR #9210 — the underlying code had diverged
~1400 commits since that PR was opened, so this is a reconstruction of
the same approach on current main rather than a clean cherry-pick.
Authorship preserved via --author on this commit.
Closes#9210
list_authenticated_providers() builds /model picker rows for CLI, TUI and
gateway flows, but fails to enumerate custom provider models stored in
dict form:
- custom_providers[] entries surface only the singular `model:` field,
hiding every other model in the `models:` dict.
- providers: dict entries with dict-format `models:` are silently dropped
and render as `(0 models)`.
Hermes's own writer (main.py::_save_custom_provider) persists configured
models as a dict keyed by model id, and most downstream readers
(agent/models_dev.py, gateway/run.py, run_agent.py, hermes_cli/config.py)
already consume that dict format. The /model picker was the only stale
path.
Add a dict branch in both sections of list_authenticated_providers(),
preferring dict (canonical) and keeping the list branch as fallback for
hand-edited / legacy configs. Dedup against the already-added default
model so nothing duplicates when the default is also a dict key.
Six new regression tests in tests/hermes_cli/ cover: dict models with a
default, dict models without a default, and default dedup against a
matching dict key.
Fixes#11677Fixes#9148
Related: #11017
Custom providers defined in config.yaml under were
completely invisible to the /model command in both gateway (Telegram,
Discord, etc.) and CLI. The provider listing skipped them and explicit
switching via --provider failed with "Unknown provider".
Root cause: gateway/run.py, cli.py, and model_switch.py only read the
dict from config, ignoring entirely.
Changes:
- providers.py: add resolve_custom_provider() and extend
resolve_provider_full() to check custom_providers after user_providers
- model_switch.py: propagate custom_providers through switch_model(),
list_authenticated_providers(), and get_authenticated_provider_slugs();
add custom provider section to provider listings
- gateway/run.py: read custom_providers from config, pass to all
model-switch calls
- cli.py: hoist config loading, pass custom_providers to listing and
switch calls
Tests: 4 new regression tests covering listing, resolution, and gateway
command handler. All 71 tests pass.
Austin Pickett
kshitij
HexLab98
Gille
Teknium
ijevin
Craig French
Deepak Jain
Alex López
kshitij
kyssta-exe 25470058+kyssta-exe@users.noreply.github.com
ajzrva-sys
luyifan
Lord_dubious
峯岸 亮
Telos
ohMyJason
zapabob
LeonSGP43
0oAstro
Rugved Somwanshi
David VV
Jason
Teknium
donrhmexe