## Problem
Since #781 a catch-all budget ("Not budgeted") yields to any budget that
tracks a
transaction by category **or** label in a period covering its date.
Reassignment is
driven by `TransactionCreated` / `TransactionUpdated`, whose listener is
`AssignTransactionToBudget`.
Pivot writes and query-builder mass updates fire no model event. So
every path that
attaches a label without a real `save()` left the transaction assigned
to whatever it
was before — typically stuck in the catch-all and missing from the
budget that tracks
its label.
In production, 44 expenses carrying one label never entered their label
budget:
`label_transaction.created_at` is ~10 minutes later than
`transactions.updated_at` on
each of them, i.e. the listener ran before the label existed and nothing
ran after.
## The paths that were broken
| Path | Write | Event |
|---|---|---|
| `AutomationRuleService::applyActions` | `saveQuietly()` +
`syncWithoutDetaching` | none |
| `AutomationRuleService::applyRuleActionsToTransactions` |
`LabelTransaction::insertOrIgnore` + mass category `update()` | none |
| `Mcp\Tools\LabelTransaction` | `syncWithoutDetaching` / `detach` |
none |
| `TransactionController::bulkUpdate` | mass category `update()` +
`labels()->sync()` | none |
The last one was found during review and is the surface users hit most —
the
bulk-actions bar in the transactions table. Its `syncLabels()` helper
does
`sync()` then `save()`, but those models are loaded before the mass
update and
nothing dirties them, so `Model::save()` skips `performUpdate()` and
fires nothing.
The docblock claiming the `save()` bumped `updated_at` was wrong and is
corrected.
## The fix
A dedicated `ReassignTransactionsToBudgets` job, dispatched from each
path, rather
than re-broadcasting `TransactionUpdated` — which would also re-run the
automation
rules that dispatched it. The job takes ids, not models, so a retry
never works from
a stale payload.
Batching, so no path queues one job per row:
- the bulk rule apply dispatches per batch of 500 ids (the AI suggestion
path is the
one caller that can hand it an unbounded list)
- `ReEvaluateTransactionRulesJob` loops `applyRules()` over the user's
whole history,
so `applyRules()` takes `reassignBudgets` and that job batches one job
per chunk
- `TransactionController::bulkUpdate` dispatches once for the whole
selection
Notifications are suppressed (`notify: false`) everywhere the change is
an
administrative edit rather than new spending: bulk rule applies,
re-evaluating rules
over history, the bulk-actions bar, and MCP relabelling. Otherwise
removing a label
would announce a months-old expense as new in the catch-all budget. The
single
transaction matched by a rule at creation time keeps notifications on.
Suppressing
them leaves `close_to_limit_notified` / `over_limit_notified` unclaimed,
so the next
genuine transaction into that budget still alerts.
A note never changes which budget counts a transaction, so a note-only
rule no longer
earns a reassignment on either path.
`applyRuleActionsToTransactions` was doing category, note and label work
inline; the
three branches are extracted so the added dispatch keeps the method
under the
repo's complexity-10 gate.
## Deploy step
This stops the state from going stale again, it does not repair what is
already
stale. After deploy:
```
php artisan budgets:reassign-labeled [--user=<email>] [--dry-run]
```
## Tests
`tests/Feature/LabelBudgetReassignmentTest.php` covers all four paths
plus the
re-evaluate batching, each asserting the transaction actually leaves the
catch-all
and lands in the label budget. All seven fail on `main` and pass here.
`AutomationRuleApplicationTest` now pins that the bulk apply queues
exactly one
reassignment job and that it is silent.
## QA
Verified in the browser against the running app with a throwaway
account: a
catch-all budget and a label budget over the same period, four expenses
starting in
the catch-all.
- Selecting all four in the transactions table and applying the label
moves
**Not budgeted $540.00 → $0.00** and **Miami 26 $0.00 → $540.00**,
confirmed in
`budget_transactions`.
- "Remove all labels" hands them back to the catch-all.
## Demo
<!-- PLACEHOLDER: drag the QA video here -->
https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/5a135257-42cf-42a7-a66a-3f76bf773e0c
## Follow-ups (not in this PR)
- Soft-deleting a label leaves its budget still counting the
transactions; the
catch-all never takes them back.
- `CategoryTree::deleteSubtree` mass-nulls `category_id` with no event,
so cascade
category deletion leaves transactions in their old category budget.
- `BudgetService::create` only adds rows for a new budget's historical
transactions;
it never removes their catch-all rows, so creating a label budget next
to an
existing catch-all double-counts until something else reassigns them.
2f00a56272